Best Upsell Apps 2026: ReConvert, CartHook, AfterSell & More
Upsell apps increase average order value 10-30%. The right app shows the right offer at the right time.
Quick Verdict:
ReConvert wins for post-purchase upsells. CartHook wins for checkout upsells (Shopify Plus). AfterSell wins for value and simplicity.
Top Upsell Apps Compared
| App | Free Tier | Paid From | Upsell Type | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| ReConvert | Dev stores | $14.99/mo | Post-purchase | Thank you page |
| CartHook | No | $49/mo | Checkout + post | Shopify Plus |
| AfterSell | No | $9.99/mo | Post-purchase | Value |
| Zipify OCU | No | $67/mo | Checkout + post | Enterprise |
| Honeycomb | Free | $24.99/mo | Funnel upsells | Funnels |
| Upsell Buddy | Free | $14.99/mo | Cart upsells | Budget |
| Selleasy | Free | $8.99/mo | Cart + post | Startups |
| Monk | Free | $19.99/mo | Cart + post | AI recommendations |
ReConvert: Best for Thank You Page
ReConvert turns your thank you page into a revenue generator. Post-purchase upsells, surveys, countdown timers, and custom widgets.
Pros: High-converting thank you page, drag-and-drop editor, A/B testing, surveys, countdown timers, good analytics.
Cons: Post-purchase only (no cart upsells), can get expensive at scale.
Pricing: Free (dev stores). Basic: $14.99/mo (up to 100 orders). Pro: $29.99/mo. Premium: $79.99/mo.
CartHook: Best for Checkout Upsells
CartHook offers checkout upsells (Shopify Plus only) + post-purchase upsells. Highest converting upsell placement.
Pros: Checkout upsells (Plus), post-purchase upsells, funnel builder, good support, high conversion rates.
Cons: Shopify Plus required for checkout upsells, expensive, limited to Shopify.
Pricing: Starts at $49/mo. Scales with order volume.
AfterSell: Best Value
AfterSell offers post-purchase upsells at affordable prices. One-click upsells, downsell offers, and funnel analytics.
Pros: Affordable, one-click upsells, downsell offers, easy setup, good for small stores.
Cons: Post-purchase only, less advanced than ReConvert, basic templates.
Pricing: Starter: $9.99/mo. Growth: $19.99/mo. Pro: $39.99/mo.
Where ReConvert Wins
1. Thank You Page Editor
Best drag-and-drop thank you page editor. Custom widgets, countdown timers, surveys, upsell offers, social proof.
2. A/B Testing
Built-in A/B testing. Test different upsell offers, page designs, widgets. Data-driven optimization.
3. Surveys
Post-purchase surveys: NPS, product feedback, shipping experience. Collect customer insights.
4. Integrations
30+ integrations: Klaviyo, Shopify Flow, Loox, Judge.me, and more.
Where CartHook Wins
1. Checkout Upsells
Only app with checkout upsells for Shopify Plus. Highest converting placement (pre-purchase).
2. Funnel Builder
Visual funnel builder. Multi-step upsell funnels. Downsell offers. Complete funnel analytics.
3. Conversion Rates
Highest reported conversion rates. Checkout upsells convert 15-25%. Post-purchase 10-15%.
Where AfterSell Wins
1. Pricing
Most affordable upsell app. $9.99/mo starter plan. Best value for small stores.
2. Simplicity
Simple setup. Easy interface. Small teams can manage. No learning curve.
2. One-Click Upsells
One-click post-purchase upsells. No re-entry of payment info. Frictionless experience.
Upsell Types Explained
Cart upsells: Offer before checkout. "Add this to your cart." Increases AOV pre-purchase.
Checkout upsells: Offer during checkout (Shopify Plus only). Highest conversion. Requires checkout.liquid access.
Post-purchase upsells: Offer after purchase on thank you page. One-click accept. No payment re-entry.
Downsell offers: Offer alternative if upsell declined. "How about this instead?"
Final Recommendation
For most stores: ReConvert. Best thank you page optimizer. Great features, good value.
For Shopify Plus: CartHook. Checkout upsells are highest converting. Worth the Plus requirement.
For budget: AfterSell. Most affordable. Good for starting with upsells.
Our pick: ReConvert for most stores. CartHook for Plus stores. AfterSell for budget-conscious.
Related Articles
Affiliate Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. We may earn a commission if you purchase through our links at no extra cost to you. We only recommend tools we've tested and trust.